Comments on: The Ethics of Killing Animals: There Is No One Answer

By: Nairu

Nairu — Fri, 09 Apr 2021 01:00:07 +0000

Still there’s a difference, if government made the effort to aware people about overpopulation and lower the birth rates there will be no need for humans to die to avoid overpopulation. But non-human animals are different, they can’t be told to stop having offspring, Wild Nature is what we call “cruel”, predators/humans kill (for food, for fun, or territory) to eliminate the weakest (younger, sick, and older) and “manage” the prey’s population, ecosystems are in constant change without human intervention (that’s one big difference between human predators and non-human predators, non-human predators kill without regulations), so that’s why we still are “cruel”, because it’s necessary for a balance and for us to live.

By: Nairu

Nairu — Fri, 09 Apr 2021 00:50:21 +0000

In reply to Dr. Georgie, MS,ND. Yep, you are definetively stupid.

By: George H Waters

George H Waters — Mon, 16 Sep 2019 15:21:53 +0000

Possibly the best article, with heartfelt pictures… that I have ever read on this subject.

By: G

Tue, 19 Mar 2019 07:57:41 +0000

I think that humans can take care and help animals too, while killing them. Hunting for survival is much better, I think, then industrial mass enslavement and slaughter NOT for survival but FOR mass sales / profit ( with the wasted/unsold products thrown away – literally thrown away). Conventional meet is often a product of lifelong slavery of an animal,ending with death in order to be just thrown away in a trash. Imagine the tragedy of unfree life and of its death of an innocent animal only so that some human animal has a chance at sales, if at all. That is immoral.
But if you kill enough to satisfy yourself, and if you have left overs,you give it to others(people or even other animals, like dogs), it is good. As a living satisfied human, now you could save another injured animal, take care of your dog, clean your forest from the trash, etc. and just help the nature in various ways. Native deer tribes in Siberia survive on deer flesh and maintain deer herds. They might kill one deer, which give them enough energy for a week to live AND to take care of the whole herd of deer: feed and protect them in cold winters. So ,the majority of deer don’t get killed but rather benefit from those humans (at the cost of an occasional kill). If there were no humans, those deer would not be as safe and open to wolve attacks much more, and that would keep their numbers down since wolves kill without taking care of the rest of the herd, as opposed to the humans. So, the natives are more fair and more ecologically friendly. They never waste their kill: every bone, every hair of their fur, every little part is used and NEVER just thrown away. The rest of deer that they don’t kill develops a bond with the natives who in turn love them back. That’s the kind of Paleo lifestyles among the tribal people that I laud.

By: Schemas and cognitive bias

Schemas and cognitive bias — Tue, 27 Nov 2018 21:48:40 +0000

Amazing article with amazing insights. Dr Georgie needs to open his mind a little bit 🙂 not all tribes live on a same lifestyle. Some will kill and be omnivores and eat whatever they can get their hands on, and some will eat fruit and be a herbavors if they want to. Lemme tell ya something – We all get to choose what lifestyle we wanna lead and we have no right in forcing other into our tribes. If i wanna be a lion and hunt for my meal I WILL DO IT. And if you wanna be a koala eating herbs all day long BE MY GUEST YOU HAVE ALL THE RIGHT TO DO SO!!!

By: Mike

Mike — Fri, 13 Jul 2018 09:23:01 +0000

God gave man dominion over animals in the garden of Eden and God himself clothed Adam and Eve in animal skins when cast from the garden. As the number of hunters dwindle it seems the simple minded try too rewrite how society has existed. I’m a breed of man that is slowly disappearing. Animals are here for three things food fur and to work for us. That’s not harsh that just the way God intended. People have lost sight of how people survived. Tell Alaska’s people to try to survive without animals. They still live as we all once did. I live in the south and remember when we had no deer or turkey to hunt but thanks to Wildlife agency’s they now flourish. I enjoy hunting my meat. It gives me a bond with our forefathers. We were made to control the circle of life.

By: Dr. Beav. R. Snacker, MD

Dr. Beav. R. Snacker, MD — Wed, 28 Mar 2018 16:03:44 +0000

In reply to Dr. Georgie, MS,ND.

…but you’re wrong. You don’t understand and won’t ever understand because of your narrow minded, between the lines, pave city view of the world. Life is not without death…Populations need death. You call humans a parasite..maybe you’re right there. We have learned to avoid death for so long..and look at the impact.
Now we have severe impacts of inbreeding and it leads to people like you being allowed to comment on the internet about subjects you actually have no idea about.
That’s your right…but it won’t ever change what happens in the real world. Just like I can’t change you being allowed to type or speak whatever incoherent blabber makes sense in nowhere except your mind.
So..as a doctor…here’s my prescription: Have a spoon full of cement…and harden the f**k up.

By: Trapper Jack ;)

Trapper Jack ;) — Wed, 28 Mar 2018 14:56:38 +0000

Is it wrong that Dr. George’s comment has given me a full blown erection?

By: Dr. Georgie, MS,ND

Dr. Georgie, MS,ND — Sat, 24 Mar 2018 03:33:54 +0000

Yep, you are NOT A SPIRITUAL person. All the views you expressed comes from the subconscious “limbic” middle brain, which is named the animal brain., for us, it called the “monkey mind”. which is responsible for “survival” so it controls, hunger, sex, addiction, rage, FEAR, neurotransmitter, like dopamine, etc. but it not the prefontal lobe that does the Math that get to the moon.
Life do not DEPENDS ON DEATH !!!! life depends on LIFE !!!!!. HUMANS ARE PARASITE!!!! on the is Earth, Plants are PRODUCERS, and we humans as primates SURVIVAL BEST as frugivores…FRUIT eaters, that why WE HAVE FULL COLOR VISION, to see THE COLORS OF ALL THE BERRIES !!!! Carnivores only SEE MOVEMENT , MAKE SENSE, since they eat LIVING ANIMALS. !!!! So everything you written, about the ORGASM you get from EATING DEAD KILLED FLESH is YOUR perverted CRAP FROM YOUR BRAINWASHING from civilization. You have NO FUR !!!, You are an INVASIVE SPECIES IN bison, wolves, moose etc. territory, that was God Given to them.